BREAKINGTOP TIER — COLLEGE FOOTBALL NEWS, ANALYSIS AND ORIGINAL REPORTING● LIVE
Top TierWriter Login
College Football

Week 2 Review: FRAUD WATCH

Week 2 is in the books and what a week it was. Upsets, comebacks, prove it games, offensive explosions and defensive stands. The season landscape has drastically changed and the Big 10 is licking its wounds.

Week 2 Review: FRAUD WATCH

SEC Dominance… and Oklahoma

As our friend Josh Pate says, we will talk about the winners first.

Mississippi State absolutely housed Minnesota on the road. Kamario Taylor looks legit and the bulldogs scored on their first four offensive possessions. State gets to find out how real they are this week against Florida.

Tennessee dominated Georgia Tech down the stretch in a game not nearly as close as the box score indicates. If not for a blocked punt due to an excessive hold by the punter, and a garbage time TD the final would have been even uglier than the 45-24 final. The Vols forced two interceptions from Alberto Mendoza and ran for nearly 300 yards behind DeSean Bishop and Duane Morris. Faizon’s stats do not jump off the page, but he led a score on the opening drive capped by a passing touchdown and did not turn the ball over.

Texas roars back in the 4th to take down the top ranked Ohio State Buckeyes. After a first quarter where everything that could go wrong did, the Longhorns held it together and adjusted. Sark proved he could win the big one. On the flip side, Ryan Day has some questions to answer.

Big 10 Highs and Lows

Indiana rolls against middling competition. Cignetti talked a lot in the off season about SEC cupcakes just for the conference to go 8-2 against power four opponents including big wins over the little 10. Meanwhile the Hoosiers have looked great against nobodies. The Hoosiers have quietly brought back a lot of defensive pieces from last year’s title run through court orders, and they may be the best shot the Big 10 has to continue their title streak.

Michigan after losing (I do not care what the box score says) to Western Michigan bounces back in a big way to knock off the Oklahoma Sooners. Kyle Wittingham put together a great game plan to manage Bryce Underwood, who was underwhelming despite the win. John Mateer and the Oklahoma offense looked lost. Makes you wonder if Michigan’s defense can keep them in some of these big games. I now have their matchup against Penn State circled on my calendar. Oklahoma on the flip side now must respond. The schedule only gets harder and an early season playoff pick could quickly be in 8-4 territory if the offensive line can’t figure it out.

We already talked about Ohio State and Texas, so I won’t rehash the game too much, but how do you blow a 20 point lead in the 4th quarter? Reminiscent of the years when Alabama could only be undone by their kicker, Ohio State was not able to hold on following a late miss from their kicker. Ryan Day has won a title before, but before that the question was always, could he manage a team in the big game. In 2024 he had the most talented roster to the tune of $40 million in NIL and road them to the national championship. But if you also remember they got dominated by Michigan before that run and lost to Oregon, the playoff number 1 seed, in the regular season. There are lingering questions about Day’s game management, but he has bounced back in the past and still has the talent to do so.

The much more baffling loss would be the Oregon Ducks in Stillwater, Oklahoma. The Pokes lost to Tulsa the week before, and it should have been by more than the box score indicated. The Cowboys were floundering through a 10-game losing streak and somehow shocked the entire college football world by beating a preseason national title favorite? Highlight of the game was Mestemaker laying his body on the line for a hurdle into the endzone on a late score to put the Cowboys up for good. Oregon has now looked lackluster in back-to-back games, and I am starting to wonder if they can pull it together. Dan Lanning lost both of his coordinators and Dante Moore has looked underwhelming despite being labeled as an NFL Draft darling.  Makes you wonder if the internet rumor about his run/pass tell being his foot placement has some legs to it. This is the first time a team on a ten game losing streak snapped it against a top 10 team.

Big 12, Bleeding Kansas and Whole Hog BBQ’s

Kansas released a hype video accusing their rival Missouri of being the cause of the Civil War and then proceeded to get boat raced in their home stadium. PR disaster for the Rock Chalks. Nobody wants to hear a sanctimonious Eli Drinkwitz in a post game presser. Missouri looks solid through two games. They have feasted off weaker SEC schedules the last few seasons and it does not look like this season will be much different. I am still waiting to see Hardy suit up following a gunshot wound in the offseason.

Utah! Those razorbacks have families! The Utes absolutely rolled the Arkansas Razorbacks who were the only other SEC team to lose to a nonconference foe so far this season. I was not sure what we would get out of Utah with the departure of Wittingham. It may say more about the state of Arkansas football than it does about Utah. Time will tell in a conference that is very compact.

Speaking of compact, the conference favorite Texas Tech has looked… very beatable. They need to figure out the QB position. The talent is there and the money has been invested. We will get to see how real they are when the Houston Cougars come to town on Friday.

ACC: an Atlantic Nightmare

I cannot make heads or tails of this conference. Clemson stinks, UNC is 2-0 with a win over a power 4 opponent and SMU coughs the ball up more than a greased pig in a butterfinger factory. Above it all is the Miami Hurricanes stat padding against bad teams and campaigning for the Malachi Toney/Darian Mensah Heisman campaigns. There is a clear front runner, but who is number two? Keep an eye on the Pitt Panthers as a sleeper, and the Louisville/SMU game this weekend. Also keep an eye on the moving truck pictured to be at Mike Norvel’s house following the firing of the Florida State Athletic Director.