A great many national pundits, sports writers, and podcast hosts would all have you believe that college football is all but dead and gone. A zombie sport, kept alive only by ESPN and bloated billionaire donors chasing ever-elusive legacy and naming rights. They say these things because college football is different very now than it was in their youths. But what they don't understand is that college football is unkillable.
When NIL and the transfer portal first came into existence, these same experts were sure that we would see a concentration of talent at the very top of the sport, and we would never see a new National Champion again, just the same 3-4 teams every year for all eternity. However, since the transfer portal officially launched 2018, there has only been one repeat winner: Georgia, who happens to be estimated to be outside the Top 20 in current NIL spending. What has actually happened is that while the top programs still get the most elite players, they pretty good players who were previously either backups or just unhappy at those programs are now starters somewhere else. The P4 schools are seeing more parity than any time in the history of the sport. Contrary to their fear-mongering, this lack of elite teams at the top has actually made each more interesting, not less.
The new worry is that next season's 24-team playoff format is going to make regular season matchups effectively "meaningless." This is short-sighted, and looking at the whole thing backwards. What they mean is that the exciting, high-profile, Top 10 matchup primetime games in November will feel like they have less on the line, because those teams will almost certainly make the playoff regardless of the outcome. They are correct in that those (very rare) games will matter less. But what will also happen, and will be a net-positive for the sport, is that more games will matter for more teams much later in the season than ever before, because virtually anyone can make the postseason if they can scratch and claw for 8+ wins against a decent schedule.
If you need proof, look no further than the last few weeks of Sooner football.
Two weeks ago, I watched the Florida game block party style, on a giant screen in the street with 50+ family, friends and neighbors, eating meats and drinking beverages and hootin' and hollerin' as the Sooners marched on their infamous 12 minute drive that led them to victory. With few reasons to have hope and plenty to avoid watching at all, we all came together anyway, and were grateful for it.
One week ago, Ole Miss did everything they could (meaning they did nothing, specifically) to get their game against OU moved to Sunday. OU fans, on short notice and in terrible weather, found a way to pack the Palace about 80% full, and fed the Sooners just enough raucous energy to grind out a gritty W. It was by all accounts a core memory for everyone there.
Fast forward to this Saturday, and fans filled the stadium past capacity once again, sounding as loud or louder than they have all season for a (then) 6-4 team with virtually no hope of making this year's 12-team playoff. Even without a larger playoff format to look forward to this year and the season essentially over, these last three games (and dozens like them around the country) still mattered, a lot. To the fans, to the players, to the coaches, and to the sport of college football.
There's just nothing else like it. Pump in all the booster money you can find. Let players change schools willy-nilly. Let everyone and their mama into the Playoff. It doesn't matter. No matter how different in looks, or how many things old men with nothing better to do have to complain about, college football will always be college football.
Writer Login
